#172 The Colours of Rum High Ester Rum - New American Oak
Review
Smell
I get some banana, pineapple, and sharpie, but even stronger is the smell of wood. There is a very complex aroma which is a bit difficult to fully describe.
Taste
This rum absolutely punches you with flavor. Very strong fruit, very strong wood, and quite tannic. Of course, also a bit of sharpie from the intensity, but absolutely delicious. Finishes with strong caramel and vanilla notes, which I enjoy.
A daiquiri with this rum has so many incredible flavors. It is such a big jump from the 1 year. I don’t normally like a really woody daiqiri, but wow! It’s so complex, lots of caramel, woody, and fruity notes. They produced so much wood flavor without losing basically any of the funk!
Verdict 9/10
(Edited from 9/10 on 11/10/26)
This one is going to have to be revisited at the end, as this is another potential contender for 10/10. The flavor is beyond what I can describe.
November 10, 2026 Update:
I’m not going to make this writeup too long since I just reviewed all of these rums recently, but I wanted to revisit my three 9/10 rums: Stolen Rum Overproof LROK, The Colours of Rum New American Oak <>H, and The Colours of Rum Bourbon DOK. How do they stack up against each other, and is there a clear favorite?
Smell:
Stolen just smells so well-rounded. You get some aged vanilla, you get some bold pineapple, banana, and blueberries, and it just smells like a wonderful creation. The COR New American and Bourbon smells more intense for sure, and you start getting some sharpie, but also, they smell more wooden, but not necessarily as vanilla and caramelly aged as the Stolen. They still smell wonderful, but perhaps slightly less well-rounded than I originally thought.
Taste:
Stolen is a very good aged Hampden. Bold pineapple, banana, and blueberries, notes of vanilla and caramel, and starts off with a buttered popcorn-y note that transforms into a smooth fruity Hampden experience. There’s basically no off flavors at all to it. New American is a different mark, and it’s a lot sharper and younger tasting. Despite being bold with wood, it tastes quite young, sharp, and sour, but still quite well rounded and delicious. The Bourbon is again quite similar: young, sharp, with a taste of wood but not necessarily the feeling of age. But it’s also just a bit smokier, and perhaps I just like the DOK mark more, but the fruity composition is superior compared to the New American.
Daiquiri:
The Stolen daiquiri is just… maybe close to the perfect daiquiri. So bright, fruity, and balanced. The aged notes are definitely there, but it’s not too woody. The rum boldly comes through and it’s delicious. The COR New American is also a fantastic daiquiri. Any other day I would love it, but having just had the Stolen, it feels like a step down. Finally, the Bourbon definitely feels like a small step up, with the smokier barrel quality and I think I just like DOK more than <>H. But overall, I am ready to deliver my verdict.
Verdict:
The Colours of Rum New American Oak impressed me before. I don’t think, having tasted it today, that I was mistaken. But, I think it should stay at a 9/10. It’s fantastic, but it’s not perfect.