#177 Dictador XO Insolent
I had a wonderful long weekend in Connecticut for Halloween, including bartending for a party where the rum punches and cocktails were an absolute hit.
Yes, October is over, and I still have DOK left. I will get on that ASAP, but I have more bottles of DOK than any other mark, so it will take a few more days. Let’s do a rum that is a bit more… storied.
Now, I know what you’re thinking: I just wrote a whole article about this rum that you can read here. How am I not biased? Well, you see, that’s actually backwards. I knew that Dictador was solera (and had the reputation that comes with that) but I thought it might be like Ron Zacapa 23: perhaps lying about its age, and perhaps quite sweet, but probably pretty good. Like, you have to admit, if you like a sweeter rum, Zacapa 23 is good. Maybe not excellent, maybe overpriced for what you’re getting, but it’s good.
The fact that Dictador was so not good is what prompted me to dig into the brand for my review, and the review turned into an article, and the article turned into two, as the lies just kept piling and piling and piling on. But the meat of the original review is from before the articles.
Review
Note: Dictador claims that this is a blend of rums aged 25-35 years in ex-Bourbon, ex-sherry, and ex-port casks. As a final step in the aging process, while it is aged in Oloroso sherry casks, the barrel is emptied, charred, and then the rum is added back to finish in the charred barrel, and this process is repeated several times.
Smell
Very woody and oaky, and very strong smell of caramel and vanilla. The aroma is overwhelming with caramel and vanilla. My initial thought was that it smells pretty nice, had I ordered an iced caramel latte. That is to say, it does not really smell like a rum. I had my Zacapa 23 out, and I put it back and took out my bottle of Old Monk XO Amber 20, because on the nose, Dictador immediately reminded me of Old Monk. Nothing but vanilla and caramel on the nose. The similarity on the nose to Old Monk XO Amber 20 is actually a bit uncanny. It smells exactly like it.
Taste
This tastes so weird. I’d say overly oaky, but also the distinct taste of something burnt. Very burnt, very bitter, and synthetic. There’s definitely a flavor of strongly toasted caramel. Also, there’s a very strong taste of vanilla, and it does taste a lot like old Monk. It really doesn’t have any burn to it, it’s very “smooth” and sweet. It is quite an interesting experience: simultaneously bitter and also sweet, and also simultaneously sour and a bit soapy. A lot of times, expert blenders can turn the bitterness, sourness, and sweetness into an orchestra, but here it’s a cocophany in my mouth. If I really let it sit and open with a bit of ice, I do get a slight hint of rum flavor, sort of that coconutty vanilla I get in bacardi rums, but it’s just such a weird flavor. Bitter, sweet, chemically, sour…
When I go to old monk, it really is like… an extremely similar flavor, with very strong vanilla and caramel, pretty sweet, yet it’s like it’s actually crafted well. It’s actually half decent, and about the best I could expect from a rum as vanilla extract-forward as Old Monk.
Verdict 3/10
I am reminded of cooking shows like Chopped or Cutthroat Kitchen where chefs are given a tough set of ingredients, but use their brains to make it work in an unconventional way. I feel like Old Monk XO Amber 20 is that with rum: I imagine the super vanilla flavor and sweetness came from the master blender at Old Monk losing a bet, but you know what? They made a product that is not only not half bad, but I actually kind of vibe with it. So for Dictador, the problem is not even the overly sweet flavor; I was prepared to give it a decently positive review while pointing out the problems with transparency, like what I wrote for Zacapa. But it’s actually bad. If it was served to me, I would think it’s cheap well rum: sweet and full of artificial flavors to hide the fact that it’s barely rum.
There’s some rums out there that are just simply bad. Caribaya white rum is simply bad. Kirkland spiced rum is simply bad. It’s cheap and the flavors suck, but they’re not pretending it’s anything but cheap mixer. Dictador XO is not simple, it’s a whole parade of flavors, all playing different, unrelated songs in my mouth. It has the styrofoam flavor of dirt cheap Dominican aguardiente, it has a burnt bitterness, a cloying sweetness, a sourness, and an overwhelming flavor of vanilla and caramel that tastes like I got a few extra pumps in my latte. And as I am writing this, the aftertaste irks me and I want to wash my mouth out. I’d be lying if I said it’s the worst rum I ever had. It’s not. But for $100 for a bottle, it’s an insult to the intelligence of anyone who buys it. It’s a tossup whether I would prefer to finish my Dictador XO or my $5 bottle of Don Rhon Silver I got in the barrios of the Dominican Republic, so I give it the same score. 3/10.
